Bedrock vs Cash Flow vs Hedge — the actual metrics

A plain-English answer to "what specific numbers decide which bucket a holding goes in?" — built from the PLEX training (Portfolio Plan + the Bedrock candidate sheet). Shared by The Property Joes Group.
Short answer: yes — the training does use a metric list, it's just spread across the Portfolio Plan video and the candidate spreadsheet. The buckets aren't decided by "vibe" or by yield — they're decided by how a fund behaves: how much it moves, how it moves relative to the stock market, how reliable the payout is, and whether you can actually hold it without margin drag. Here's the whole list in one place, with the direction each bucket wants.

The three buckets in one line each

Bedrockstability first. Low drawdown, low correlation, low maintenance. Yield is a bonus, not the goal. Target ~65%.

Cash Flowthe yield engine. You accept higher volatility and some NAV erosion in exchange for high income. Target ~34%.

Hedgeportfolio insurance. Moves opposite the market, asymmetric bets, tiny allocation. Target ~1%.

The metric list — and which direction each bucket wants it

Metric (from the candidate sheet)What it tells youBedrock wantsCash FlowHedge
Correlation to the S&P 500Does it move with the stock market? (0 = independent, 1 = lockstep)Low — own clock, not the market'sCan be high (equity-linked OK)Negative — moves opposite
Standard deviation (volatility)How violently the price swings around its averageLow (a senior-loan CEF ≈ 4 qualifies)Higher OK (CLO-equity ≈ 12–18)High but asymmetric
Max drawdownWorst peak-to-trough fall historicallyShallowDeeper tolerated for yieldn/a (it's the insurance)
Distribution rate (yield)The headline payout %Modest — the LAST thing you optimizeHigh — this is the pointVery high (mostly ROC)
Distribution frequency & reliabilityHow often it pays and whether the payout holds upMonthly & steady preferredHigh but can be lumpyVariable
Maintenance / margin requirementCan your broker hold it cheaply? (high req = unusable)Low — must be holdableLow–moderateTiny position, less critical
Morningstar starsQuality sanity-checkA tiebreaker for all three — not the driver
Return-of-capital (ROC) shareIs the "yield" real income or your own money handed back?MinimalSome is OKMostly ROC

These are the exact columns scored in the Academy's "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates" sheet: Distribution Rate · Frequency · Correlation to S&P 500 · Standard Deviation · Morningstar Stars · broker Maintenance Requirement.

What matters MOST for each bucket (priority order)

BucketDecide in this order →
Bedrock1. price stability → 2. max drawdown → 3. market correlation → 4. maintenance requirement → 5. then yield
Cash Flow1. yield → 2. dividend reliability → 3. spread/discount
Hedge1. negative correlation → 2. asymmetric payoff

The order is the whole point: for Bedrock, yield comes last; for Cash Flow, it comes first. Same fund universe, opposite priorities.

How it works in practice — one real example

The cleanest way to see it: take the same metric and watch it decide the bucket. From the candidate sheet:

So the rule of thumb the metrics produce: low std-dev + low correlation + low maintenance + steady monthly payout → Bedrock. Crank up the volatility or the yield-chasing → it's Cash Flow. Built to move against the market on an asymmetric bet → Hedge.

Quick decision rule

When you're unsure where a holding goes, ask in this order:

  1. Is it built to move opposite the market / is it an asymmetric option-income bet?Hedge (and keep it tiny).
  2. Is it low-volatility, low-correlation, easy to hold, and you'd own it even if the yield were boring?Bedrock.
  3. Are you holding it mainly for the big distribution, accepting the swings?Cash Flow.

If a fund "could" be Bedrock but you only want it for the yield, the priority order settles it: Bedrock screens on stability first, so a yield-motivated pick belongs in Cash Flow.

Key terms — and where each is taught in the Academy

TermMeaningWhere it's taught (course · session · date)
BedrockStability bucket — low drawdown/correlation/maintenance; yield is the last screen. Target ~65%.PLEX · Community Call "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025 (also PLEX tier model)
Cash FlowThe yield engine — accepts volatility & NAV erosion for income. Target ~34%.PLEX · Call 2 "PLEX Portfolio" · Feb 2, 2026 (PLEX tier model)
HedgeTiny asymmetric insurance sleeve that moves opposite the market. Target ~1%.PLEX · "The Ultimate Hedge Against Inflation" · Sep 2024
Correlation (to the S&P 500)How closely two things move together: ~0 = independent, ~1 = lockstep, negative = opposite.PLEX · "Qualifying New Income Sources" (Income-Source Criteria) · May 4, 2022 · scored in "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025
Standard deviationA volatility measure — bigger number = wilder price swings.PLEX · "Qualifying New Income Sources" · May 4, 2022 · column in "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025
Distribution rate & frequencyThe payout % and how often/reliably it pays (monthly & steady preferred).PLEX · "Qualifying New Income Sources" · May 4, 2022 · candidate sheet, "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025
Maintenance / margin requirementHow much a broker makes you hold against a position; very high = effectively unusable in the plan.PLEX · Call 3 "Margin" · Feb 9, 2026 · scored in "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025
Morningstar starsA quality sanity-check / tiebreaker, not the driver.PLEX · candidate-sheet column, "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025
NAV erosionA fund's per-share value grinding lower over time even while it pays a high yield.PLEX · "Income Sources — Advanced: Open-End Funds (Part 2)"
Return of capital (ROC)A "distribution" that's partly your own money returned — it isn't true income and it erodes NAV.PLEX · "Income Sources — Advanced: Open-End Funds (Part 2)"
CEF (closed-end fund)Fixed share count, often leveraged, can trade at a discount/premium to NAV.PLEX · "Income Sources — Advanced: Open-End Funds (Part 2)"
BDCBusiness Development Company — lends to private mid-market businesses; high yield, equity-like risk.PLEX · "Qualifying New Income Sources" · May 4, 2022 (BDC examples in "Bedrock Candidates v2.0")
CLO / CLO-equityCollateralized loan obligation; the equity tranche is the riskiest slice — high yield, high volatility → Cash Flow, not Bedrock.PLEX · "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" · Apr 16, 2025 (CLO candidates: ECC/OXLC/OCCI)

Citations point to the Fynanc PLEX curriculum: the income-source qualification criteria (originally "Qualifying New Income Sources," May 4 2022), the PLEX tier model, and the metric columns in the "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" community call (Apr 16 2025). "0DTE / weekly covered-call" and "YieldMax / single-stock option income" are general market products referenced in PLEX portfolio examples rather than terms coined by the course.

Bottom line for the question: yes, there is a metric list — it's the candidate-sheet columns above (correlation, standard deviation, drawdown, distribution rate & frequency, maintenance, ROC), and the trick is the priority order: Bedrock screens for stability and treats yield as last; Cash Flow leads with yield; Hedge leads with negative correlation. Run any holding down the metric list and the bucket falls out.
Educational summary for the Fynanc community · sourced from the PLEX training: Portfolio Plan module and the "Bedrock Debt-Based Candidates v2.0" community call (Apr 16, 2025) · figures are illustrative reference values from the candidate sheet, not advice · prepared by The Property Joes Group.
📚Library